News & Info

What impact do pre-existing conditions have on personal injury claims?

This is a common question we are frequently asked by clients. Solicitor Elaine Hickey explains all you need to know.

Summary

  • Having a pre-existing condition does not rule out compensation. If the condition was made worse because of an accident, you may be able to claim for this.
  • It is vital that all medical conditions are disclosed when making a personal injury claim, so the impact on any existing injuries can accurately be assessed.
  • A failure to disclose a pre-existing condition could cause your case to be dismissed.
  • If you are waiting for your injury to heal before making a personal injury claim, and you delay too long, you may miss your time limit for being able to seek compensation.

“Too often people mistakenly believe they are unable to claim for an injury that was worsened by a road traffic accident or accident at work, because it is a pre-existing condition,” explains Elaine. “But in many cases, if a pre-existing condition has been exacerbated by an accident, it could still be eligible for compensation.”

“The fact is, if an incident that was caused by someone else’s negligence has aggravated a pre-existing injury or condition, you are entitled to take legal action for the aggravation of this injury,” she adds.

Below Elaine answers some of the common questions we are asked about how pre-existing conditions are assessed in personal injury claims.

I have a pre-existing medical condition. Does this mean that I can’t claim?

No. Having a pre-existing condition does not rule out compensation. If the condition was made worse because of an accident, you may still be able to claim for this.

Can I make a personal injury claim if I had a pre-existing back injury before an accident?

Yes, you could claim for a pre-existing back injury that was made worse by an accident.

For example, you had occasional back pain before you were in a road traffic accident, and the impact of the collision aggravated the existing condition. In this case, the aggravated existing condition will be assessed, as well as the impact this has on your day-to-day life.

So if your back pain was manageable before, but became worse after the accident, and as a result you were unable to work, or do your normal daily activities, this is what would be compensated for.

This case study shows how we were able to help a client who had a pre-existing back condition that worsened after the accident.

Every case is different and each client has their own unique medical history that will need to be assessed on its own merits. To understand more, read our short overview of pre-existing injuries.

The main points to remember are:

  • pre-existing conditions are still valid for personal injury claims if an accident has made them worse.
  • all medical conditions should be fully disclosed in every personal injury claim.

What about pre-existing mental health conditions?

Yes. If you have an existing mental health condition and this has been made worse because of an accident, it can be considered as part of your personal injury claim.

The Injuries Resolution Board and/or the Courts will look at the impact the accident had on your daily life, and this includes your mental health.

For example, if you are unable to sleep, or if you suffer depression following an accident, this can have a significant effect on your daily life and can be compensated for.

Read this road traffic accident case study to learn more about how we were able to secure compensation for a client whose mental health condition worsened after an accident.

How do the Courts assess pre-existing conditions?

Depending on the circumstances, compensation may take account of additional pain and suffering, medical expenses, loss of earnings and other financial losses caused by the accident.

The Judicial Council’s Personal Injury Guidelines are used by the Injuries Resolution Board and the Courts to enable them to ensure consistency in the awards of monetary damages in successful personal injuries claims. The Irish Personal Injuries Guidelines specifically address pre-existing conditions:

“If a claimant has a pre-existing condition that is aggravated by an injury for which the court is assessing compensation, it should have regard only to the extent to which the condition had been made worse and the duration of any increased symptomology.”

This means the assessment will look at the additional impact of the accident on the existing injury or medical condition.

Medical evidence will be essential in establishing the extent of the deterioration, how long the increased symptoms have lasted and whether any lasting effects are expected.

Should I tell my solicitor about all of my pre-existing conditions? Even the ones that were not made worse by the accident?

Absolutely. You should always tell your solicitor about any pre-existing medical conditions, previous injuries or relevant medical treatment, even if you do not believe they are connected to your accident.

Many people worry that disclosing a previous injury will weaken their claim. However, being open and honest about your medical history is essential to building a strong personal injury case.

Your solicitor needs to understand your medical background so they can assess how the accident affected you.

By discussing your medical history openly with your solicitor, they can:

  • identify which pre-existing conditions may be relevant to your claim,
  • understand your health and physical capabilities before the accident,
  • request appropriate medical reports and supporting evidence,
  • demonstrate how the accident caused additional injury or deterioration of your health,
  • present a clear and accurate account of the impact the accident has had on your life.

What happens if I do not disclose a pre-existing condition?

If something is omitted that is subsequently revealed during a medical examination, this can lead to difficulty if the case ends up in court.

You may think that an unrelated injury you sustained years before the accident is not worth mentioning.

However a defendant may allege that you are not a credible claimant as you deliberately withheld information.

Deliberately withholding or misrepresenting relevant information can cause a personal injury claim to be dismissed.

Do I need to wait for my injuries to heal before making a claim?

No. You do not need to wait until your injuries have healed before talking to a personal injury solicitor. Remember, there is a strict time limit on when you can make a claim: this is only two years minus one day from the date of the accident or date of knowledge of your injuries. But it takes time to process a claim, so the sooner you act, the better.

Contact us today for a no-obligation discussion about your case

If you were injured in an accident, and are unsure of what your legal rights are, contact us today for a no-obligation discussion about your case.

Our experienced team will listen to what happened to you, assess whether you have a valid claim, and let you know what the next steps may be.

 

Disclaimer: This article has been prepared by Tracey Solicitors LLP for general guidance only and should not be regarded as a substitute for professional advice.